Comparison
Seven ways to see the best posts in your niche, side by side: what each one does, what it costs, and what it leaves out. We list where we fall short before where we win.
Built from each tool's own pages, checked 30 October 2026. We haven't tested their products.
The short answer
Tools that find top Instagram posts fall into three groups. Creator tools like Octupie, Sandcastles and Mysocial Outliers flag posts that beat their creator's usual and help you write your version, with entry prices of $23 to $49 a month. Analytics suites like Rival IQ and Socialinsider benchmark brands over months of history and start at $82 to $239 a month. Instagram's own tool is free and compares you with up to 10 accounts, but doesn't say why a post worked. SocialToolsAI sits between the first and third: it finds your competitors, shows their posts that beat their own usual, and sends free ideas picked from them each week. It's Instagram only, shows 30 days, and doesn't write full scripts or reports yet. If you need those, one of the others is the better fit.
Our data
Most tools here score a post against its own account for this reason. The numbers come from our study of 7,887 public business accounts, each with its last 12 posts.
Median followers by usual likes
| Account's usual post | Accounts | Median followers |
|---|---|---|
| Under 10 likes | 1,011 | 6,623 |
| 10 to 39 | 1,301 | 4,280 |
| 40 to 99 | 1,400 | 9,655 |
| 100 to 499 | 2,065 | 42,617 |
| 500 and up | 2,107 | 372,946 |
What it means
5.8x
the account's usual likes: the median for the best post of its last 12
A post at 5x its own usual is ordinary. Sort a niche by raw likes and you mostly rank audience size, so the posts worth learning from, the ones that beat their own account, get buried under big accounts' normal days.
These are accounts that appear in niches our users research, so they skew towards businesses doing at least okay. Twelve posts is a short window, and likes are one signal. Full method and caveats in the study.
Side by side
“Not listed” (in grey) means we looked at the tool's own pages and they don't say. It doesn't mean the tool can't do it. Each tool's name links to the page we used.
| SocialToolsAI | Octupie | Sandcastles | Mysocial Outliers | Rival IQ | Socialinsider | Instagram's own tool | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| How you add competitors | Describe your business and who you want to find, and a search adds the closest accounts. Add or remove any by hand. | Says it maps your niche's top accounts at sign-up, and you can add your own. We haven't tested how well the mapping works. | You build a watchlist of channels, and search a video database. Its Claude help page says it can also find channels in your niche. | Topic search (their page says it runs on hashtags) or paste a creator's link. | You add each company. Suggestions aren't listed. | You add each brand. A G2 reviewer notes it's one by one. | Up to 10 public professional accounts. Third-party coverage says Instagram suggests some. |
| Post scored against its own account's usual | Yes. Every post is shown against its own account's usual, for the last 7 or 30 days. | Yes, shown as a multiple (their example: 5.7x their usual). | Yes, an outlier score, filterable. | Yes, against the creator's median for each format (reels, carousels, images). | Breakout alerts exist. How a breakout is scored isn't listed. | Top posts by content category. Scoring isn't listed. | Per-post performance is listed. Scoring against usual isn't. |
| Why a post worked | Paid: a short read on why each post worked. | Yes: hook, on-screen elements, structure. | Yes: deep analysis of hook, storytelling and format, one credit each. | Yes on paid plans: reels transcribed, every carousel slide analysed. Comment text isn't analysed yet. | Not listed. | Says it analyses what drives top posts (caption length, format). | Not listed. |
| Ideas or scripts | Free: 3 ideas a week, picked automatically from competitors' best posts. Paid: 10 a week, plus 20 a month from any post you choose. Hooks and shot lists, not full scripts. | Scripts in your voice. 30 a month on Creator, unlimited (fair use) on Pro. | Hooks and scripts, one credit each. | Save a post to Ideas, then draft with your own AI. | Not listed. | Not listed. | Not listed. |
| Alerts | Paid: comments asking to buy or complaining, falling likes, missed posting days. No alert for a competitor's breakout post. | Weekly niche email and breakout alerts on paid plans. | Not listed. | Not listed. | Yes. Breakout-post alerts by email or in the app, live or weekly. | Not listed. | Not listed. |
| Free option | Free plan with no time limit and no card: 1 client, 25 competitors. | 7-day trial, no card. No free plan. | No free plan. Its trial length is shown as both 7 and 30 days. | A free plan, but Outliers isn't in it. | 14-day trial, no card. | 14-day trial, no card. | Free. |
| How fresh the data is | Competitors every 24 hours on paid, every 72 on free. Your own account every 6 hours on paid. | Niche breakout feed updated daily. | Every 12, 6 or 1 hour by plan, per one review site. | Tracked creators re-checked every 48 hours, or every 6 on team plans. | Not listed. | Not listed. | Not listed. |
| How far back it goes | 30 days, no archive. | Not listed. | Not listed. | Not listed for content. A tracked creator's usual is the 90 days before each post. | 6, 12 or 24 months by plan. | 3, 6 or 12 months by plan. | Your choice of 30, 60 or 90 days. |
| Platforms | Instagram only. | Instagram only. | Instagram, TikTok, YouTube Shorts. | YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn, Threads. | Several networks. | Several networks. | Instagram only. |
| Starting price | Free. Paid from $19 a month for one client. | $23 a month billed yearly ($29 monthly), 75 competitors. | $39 a month billed yearly ($49 monthly), 150 competitors per workspace. | $49 a month for Outliers (its page lists 3 tracked creators a month). | $239 a month for 10 companies. | $82 a month (their page doesn't say which billing cycle). | Free. |
Where we fall short
If one of these is your main need, don't pick us.
Sandcastles covers TikTok and Shorts too, and Mysocial five platforms. We don't look beyond Instagram.
Rival IQ keeps 6 to 24 months of history and Socialinsider 3 to 12. We show the last 30 days of competitor posts and keep nothing after you cancel.
Octupie and Sandcastles write a script from a breakout post. Our ideas give a hook, a shot list and the reasoning, but not a script in your voice.
Rival IQ and Octupie list alerts for a competitor's breakout post. Ours are about your own account and comments, and new standouts wait in Top posts.
That page isn't built. If you send monthly reports to clients, use Rival IQ or Socialinsider for now.
What we do
We didn't find these on the other tools' pages. That's different from saying they don't have them.
On the free plan, three ideas a week are picked from your competitors' best posts and arrive on your client's weekday. You don't choose a post or spend a credit.
One client and up to 25 competitors, refreshed every 72 hours, with no card and no time limit. The creator tools here start with a paid plan or a trial.
Paid plans read comments on your client's posts and flag the unanswered ones that ask to buy or complain.
See which brands, vendors and hosts your competitors work with, and how those posts did against their usual. Free shows the top 5 partners, paid shows all of them ranked by fit.
Top posts are rated by how close each one is to your client's own kind of business, so a big unrelated account doesn't crowd out the relevant ones.
Each paid slot is one client with its own competitors. A plan starts at $19 a month for one client and gets cheaper per client as you add more.
Our data
Mysocial says its topic search runs on hashtags, and that's the usual way. We tested our search against a plain keyword match on one med spa's 480 posts from 30 days. These are the shares of the posts that really matched, found by each method.
| Search for | Keyword match found | Our search found |
|---|---|---|
| Halloween | 13% | 90% |
| meet the team | 14% | 82% |
| discounts and specials | 0% | 97% |
Caveats: one account, one month, captions only (the product also reads pictures now). The matches were labelled by one AI reviewer reading whole captions, with no second rater, so treat the gaps as a direction, not a precise measure. Free plans get three post searches a month, paid plans 30 a month per client.
Which one to pick
You make short-form Instagram video and want a script in your own voice written for each breakout.
Closest to us in what it sets out to do. It writes the script, we don't. We haven't tested its niche mapping on a local business.
You post to Instagram, TikTok and Shorts, and want a big watchlist with scripts and an AI assistant connection.
Credits run out each month and don't roll over, per reviews of it.
You want reels and carousels transcribed and read slide by slide, and you want to feed that to your own AI.
Outliers starts on a paid plan, and the page's example limits are small.
You report to a team or clients, want alerts when a competitor has a breakout post, and need up to two years of history.
It's the priciest here, and its reviewers say it tells you what happened more than what to do.
You want benchmarks against competitors or an industry, with months of history beyond the 30 days Instagram's own app keeps.
Brands are added one by one, and its pages don't list ideas or alerts.
You have a professional account and only need follower growth, posting frequency and per-post numbers against up to 10 accounts.
It's free. It doesn't tell you why a post worked or what to post.
Today that means a paid plan from $19 a month for one client, or the free plan.
How we built this page
It depends on what you do next. If you want a script written in your voice, Octupie and Sandcastles go further than we do. If you report to clients and want months of history, Rival IQ and Socialinsider are built for that. If you want the best posts picked from your competitors automatically, with ideas arriving each week and a free plan to start, that's what we built. The table above lists where each one stands on the same ten points.
Because audience size drives raw likes. In our study of 7,887 business accounts, the accounts whose usual post gets under 10 likes had a median of 6,623 followers, and the ones at 500 or more had 372,946. Sort a niche by likes and you mostly sort by who has the biggest audience. The best post of an account's last 12 was a median 5.8x its usual, so a post at 5x its own usual is normal, and 10x or more is the one worth studying.
Both. Describe your business and the kind of accounts you want, and a search finds them and adds the closest ones. You can also add any account by hand and mark ones as not relevant. Octupie says it maps a niche too, and Sandcastles and Mysocial start from your watchlist or a topic search, so this isn't unique, but it's how our free plan starts.
One client, up to 25 competitors, new posts every 72 hours, three ideas a week picked from your competitors' best posts, three post searches a month and five saved posts. Paid plans refresh competitors every 24 hours and your own account every 6, track up to 100 competitors per client, and add alerts, a read on why each post worked, and more ideas.
Free to start with no card. A paid plan is $19 a month for one client, and each extra client costs less. Prices come from the same catalog checkout uses.
It's Instagram only. It shows the last 30 days of competitor posts and keeps no archive. It doesn't write scripts in your voice, and it has no client report page yet. It doesn't send an alert the moment a competitor has a breakout post: those posts show up in Top posts with a count of what's new since your last visit. If any of those is the main thing you need, the table says who does it.
No. Every competitor fact on this page comes from the tool's own site, pricing page or help centre, or from the third-party source linked next to it, as of 30 October 2026. We haven't signed up to them. Where a page doesn't say, the table says "Not listed", which isn't the same as "No". If something is out of date, tell us and we'll fix it.
No. You don't log in with Instagram or share a password, and only public profile information is used.
Add your client or business, and the free plan finds competitors and shows the posts that beat their own usual. No card, no Instagram login.
Start freeRelated